Crossword Answer really

Here are all the crossword puzzles and clues where the answer really appeared.

Clue
Puzzle
Date
"Are you serious?"
USA Today
Jan 15, 2024
"Are you pulling my leg?"
New York Times
Jul 16, 2023
"Are you being serious?"
Daily Beast
Feb 2, 2023
“Is that so?”
Eugene Sheffer
Jan 28, 2023